Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Celebrities > Dune > Re: Different v...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 4 of 6 Topic 918 of 1018
Post > Topic >>

Re: Different versions of "Dune?"

by Stoned in Arrakeen <sia@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Nov 9, 2007 at 05:44 PM

58Retire, confused, wrote:
 >
 > After reading the 6 prequels, I thought it was appropriate to break
 > my general rule of never re-reading a book.. After all, maybe I will
 > understand Dune this time...
 >
Yes. But then, maybe you won't.
 >
 > My questions:
 > 1. the end of the book is significantly different that I remember.
 > I distinctly remember Jessica being kidnapped and forced to train
 > the na-Baron H.  This does not happen in this version
 >
I think it's probably appropriate to break your general rule of never 
re-reading the other 5 books in the sequence as well. After all, maybe 
you will understand Dune this time...
 >
 > 2. also the chapter "squib" were largely from encyclopedias,
 > religious books, etc.  In this version, it is various sayings by
 > or about "Maud-dib"
 >
Most of which come from encyclopedias, religious books, etc.
 >
 > 3. finally, the Dune I remember is much thicker and took
 > much more than 10 hours to read.
 >
Re-read, and keep your eyes on the page-numbers. There's a good chance 
that someone has been removing pages from your copy for nefarious 
purposes. And, with practice over the past few years, you are now a 
faster reader.
 >
 > Ok, here is the question.  Is there two versions,
 > like some of the King books?
 >
Check the publisher. If you see the words "Reader's Digest Condensed 
Version" anywhere, then you've probably managed to get hold of a 
Reader's Digest Condensed Version.
 >
 > Or am I totally confusing Dune with another book set in
 > the far future?
 >
That's a distinct possibility. Or maybe you're reading some of the King 
books by mistake.
 >
 > thanks!
 >
No problem. Just you hang on in there.
 




 6 Posts in Topic:
Different versions of "Dune?"
58Retire <google@[EMAI  2007-11-08 12:44:12 
Re: Different versions of "Dune?"
Freakzilla <jlkiv@[EMA  2007-11-08 14:34:17 
Re: Different versions of "Dune?"
"Tony" <tony  2007-11-09 04:29:11 
Re: Different versions of "Dune?"
Stoned in Arrakeen <si  2007-11-09 17:44:21 
Re: Different versions of "Dune?"
SandChigger <sandchigg  2007-11-09 15:01:25 
Re: Different versions of "Dune?"
Stoned in Arrakeen <si  2007-11-10 03:02:27 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Thu Jul 24 4:04:25 CDT 2008.