Talk About Network



Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Celebrities > Dirk Pitt > Re: Writers who...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 1 of 17 Topic 5 of 86
Post > Topic >>

Re: Writers who jumped the shark

by El Capitan <pirate@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Jun 26, 2003 at 04:35 PM

In article <34e2d56d.0306261227.690eed1d@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>,
 purple_bovine@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 (Larisa) wrote:

> aalucard@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 wrote in message 
> news:<29485-3EFA844F-32@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>...
> > What writers do you think have jumped the shark. 
> > 
> It pains me to say this, but I will anyway: Carl Hiaasen.  I fervently
> hope that "Basket Case" was just an isolated occurrence and not a
> harbinger of things to come.
> 
> LM

While Hiaasen is truly funny, I think he's gone to the well once too 
many times.  That field of wacky Florida authors is getting a little 
thick.  They all come off as Elmore Leonard's goofy kid brother.

Let's see, you've got Hiaasen, who peaked with Native Tongue, IMHO. 
Stormy Weather, Basket Case, Sick Puppy & Lucky You were only so-so.

Then there's Dave Barry, who writes the same (somewhat funny) column 
over & over, and has now branched into the same vein of novels.  I 
actually liked the movie Big Trouble more than the book.  I've got his 
other one in the 'to read' pile.

There's also Tim Dorsey.  His books have a wickedly funny, almost cruel 
streak that surfaces every now & then, but overall the books are just OK.

In other genres, Gerald Browne, who wrote many novels about Beautiful 
People committing jewel/cash heists jumped the shark with 18mm Blues.

Clive Cussler (Dirk Pitt series) jumped the shark when he started 
inserting himself as a character into his own novels.  Amusing the first 
time, but got really old after that. (Someone in another thread 
mentioned something about shattering your suspension of disbelief.)

Tom Clancy lost it (if he ever had it...) with Debt of Honor.  Grisham & 
Crichton lost it with the first novels they wrote strictly as fodder for 
screenplays.

ObSF - For Skiffy/Fantsy authors, I agree wholeheartedly about Robert 
Jordan having jumped the shark.  The only other author that comes close 
to Jordan's diarrhea of the keyboard was L. Ron Hubbard (or whatever 
Scientology committee wrote that 10 volume set.)  I read the 1st three 
books of Jordan's Wheel of Time and got started on the 4th, but then the 
Eight Deadly Words set in.

Others that have gone past their expiration date...
(putting on flameproof suit for this one... and YES, I know he's dead...)
Douglas Adams - anything past Restaurant EXCLUDING Dirk Gently stuff.

Piers Anthony, Terry Brooks, Simon R. Green, Katherine Kurtz, Joel 
Rosenberg & the Weis/Hickman conglomerate will have to come up with some 
pretty unique material before they get any more of my money.

Your Mileage May Vary...

El Capitan

-- 
A rose by any other name would be "deadly thorn-bearing assault
vegetation."




 17 Posts in Topic:
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
El Capitan <pirate@[EM  2003-06-26 16:35:49 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
tomcatpolka@[EMAIL PROTEC  2003-06-26 21:57:48 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
apbrezen@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2003-06-26 22:09:34 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
mrfeathers@[EMAIL PROTECT  2003-06-26 23:25:56 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
Lawrence Watt-Evans <l  2003-06-26 23:30:23 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
Eric Jarvis <web@[EMAI  2003-06-27 00:54:08 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
"Christopher Adams&q  2003-06-27 19:01:18 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
Terry Pinnell <terrypi  2003-06-30 20:56:55 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
Sean O'Hara <darkerthe  2003-06-26 19:24:25 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
darklensman@[EMAIL PROTEC  2003-06-26 23:30:40 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
Eric Jarvis <web@[EMAI  2003-06-27 16:14:36 
(really, writers who DIDN'T) Re: Writers who jumped the shark
"Christopher J. Henr  2003-06-28 14:21:07 
Re: (really, writers who DIDN'T) Re: Writers who jumped the shar
Jeff Shultz <jeff@[EMA  2003-06-29 03:54:54 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
Luna <lunachick@[EMAIL  2003-06-27 09:38:28 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
"WareWolf" <  2003-06-28 01:01:26 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
anotherwriter@[EMAIL PROT  2003-06-27 12:17:25 
Re: Writers who jumped the shark
Benjamin Adams <benada  2003-06-27 16:31:01 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sat May 17 10:05:01 CDT 2008.